Ah, the eternal question: cork or screw cap? It’s a debate that never seems to end in the wine world, and a mini mental war we all wage in the wine aisle.
Choosing the right bottle for the right occasion can already feel like a science experiment, so why am I here making things harder by bringing up another decision point? Because… well, it’s worth uncorking (or unscrewing) this conversation over a glass of something delicious.
Let’s take a deep breath, pour ourselves a glass, and consider both sides. Just like you shouldn’t judge a book by its cover, you definitely shouldn’t judge a wine by how it’s sealed.
The Romance of Cork
When does the true enjoyment of wine begin? Is it with the first sip? The swirl in the glass? Maybe when you start pretending to pick up "notes of wild cherry and wet stone"? Nope! it starts the moment you hear that satisfying pop as the cork is pulled from the bottle. That small sound is a whole mood. A ceremony.
There’s an undeniable romance to cork. It brings a sense of tradition, of ritual. There’s something tactile and ceremonial in slicing the foil, plunging the corkscrew, and finally hearing that iconic release. It’s an experience many of us associate with “real wine.”
And let’s not forget how corks are made—it’s pretty fascinating. Cork comes from the bark of the Cork Oak (Quercus suber, if we are being fancy), grown primarily in Portugal, Spain, and parts of North Africa. These trees aren’t harmed in the process; just gently stripped every nine years by skilled harvesters. The bark is then boiled, dried, and crafted into the stoppers we know and love. It’s artisanal, sustainable, and steeped in history.
The Convenience of the Screw Cap
Now, let’s talk about the underdog-turned-hero: the screw cap.
First introduced in the late 1950's, screw caps quickly became the go-to closure in Australia and New Zealand. Why? Science. Studies showed screw caps are excellent at preserving fruit-forward aromas and flavors, especially in white wines and younger reds. No cork taint. No crumbling. Just pure wine, sealed tight.
Screw caps are also more practical for both winemakers and wine drinkers. They’re cost-effective, easy to use, and perfect for those moments when you don’t want to fumble with a corkscrew, or don’t have one. Want to save the rest for later? Twist it back on and you are good to go.
Still, some of us hesitate when gifting a screw-capped bottle, worried it might feel “cheap” or “less serious.” But that perception is changing.... and fast. More and more high-quality wines are proudly topped with screw caps, and rightly so.
So, What’s the Verdict?
Here’s the truth: it’s not what’s on top that matters, it’s what’s inside the bottle. If we could just let go of the outdated idea that screw caps signal lower quality, wine shopping, and drinking, would be so much easier. Especially when you're trying to impress someone with a bottle of wine whether it pops or twists, make sure it pours well.
So next time you are picking a bottle, don’t overthink it. Cork or screw cap, what matters most is the wine, the moment, and who you share it with. Cheers to that.
(Need help choosing a bottle that’s sure to impress? Click below for some crowd-pleasing picks.)
Supermarket wines under £10 that are a bargain
Wine under HK$100 in Hong Kong's supermarkets
''At the end of the day, you really can’t make a wrong choice.
As long as you pay attention to what it is that you don’t like about a wine
each bottle will get you closer to what you do like.
Take it one glass at a time!''